The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct review

by James O'Connor Featured

14 Comments 31 Votes 24585 Views 27/03/2013 Back to Reviews
What Survival Instinct Got Right
  • + Glimmers of good ideas pop up here and there
  • + At least makes some attempts at being a competent survival horror
What Survival Instinct Got Wrong
  • - Combat is a shambles
  • - It looks like a lazy PS2 port
  • - Unreliable systems abound
  • - Numerous awful design choices

We’ve suspected for a while that The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct would be bad. The very concept – a first person shooter based on the television show – tasted pretty sour to mouths still savouring the flavours of Telltale’s wonderful episodic offerings, and the first footage we saw was legendarily horrendous. We expected a bit of a glorious train wreck; the sort of game that we could laugh through the tears on, like Night Trap or Big Rigs Racing. Instead, Survival Instinct is a bit of a sad failure, one that was obviously rushed out the door as fast as humanly possible.

You’re placed in the redneck boots of Daryl Dixon (who is, apparently, a fan favourite: I’ve largely stuck to the comics myself), whose quest to find his brother Merle makes up what little story the game possesses.

If you’re using a melee weapon against a single zombie, it will simply stand still while you stab it in the face.

Structurally, Survival Instinct has some smart ideas – instead of progressing straight from level to level, you’re faced with a map in-between sorties and given options as to which destinations you’re going to set, and how you’re going to get to them. Travelling between waypoints, and can choose to either take main roads, highways or back alleys, which vary your chances of running out of fuel, finding resources or suffering from a breakdown.

The problems start the moment any of these things occur and you’re forced out of your car. When you’re out in the field, hunting and stabbing away at zombies, Survival Instinct is shockingly inadequate on every level. Whenever a zombie gets all up in your face it feels like a morose riff on ZombiU.

If you’re using a melee weapon against a single zombie, it will simply stand still while you stab it in the face – if you’re facing multiple enemies and don’t want to attract more with gunshots, you’re screwed unless you can climb to higher ground. Stand on a car, a bench, anything higher than your waist really, and the zombies will have a hell of a hard time getting to you, letting you to leisurely stab them all in the face (which will take ages).

This is all clearly partly intentional – zombies are best avoided in general – but these encounters are just so unendingly dull. It doesn’t help that there only seem to be about eight generic zombie models, or that they constantly swarm you at inopportune times. The encounters with zombies simply feel ill-conceived and irritating rather than intense, which is a problem for a game based entirely around fending them off.

There are very few areas to explore along the way, but some of them can take time to work through properly, especially if you concern yourself with the bothersome side-missions that pop up from other survivors. The fact that you can’t save mid-mission and come back later is intensely irritating, and if you die on your way to one of the ‘main’ areas, any progress you made during pit-stops is lost. It’s simply bad design through and through, and there’s really nothing to redeem it – no clever winks for fans, no interesting story elements to speak of, and no graphics that wouldn’t have been heavily criticised on the PS2.

But Survival Instinct’s worst crime, by far, is the way it peppers its campaign with moments and ideas that, while not brilliant, at least hint at a level of creative thought that went into the title. Were you able to pull aside one of the game’s designers, it’s not hard to imagine that they’d put the game’s faults down to budget and time restrictions, withheld resources, and trampled ambition rather than laziness. This is one of the most genuine attempts at survival horror we’ve seen in ages. There’s a low ammo count, few health pick-ups, an emphasis on evasion over confrontation, and a handful of horror-movie moments scattered throughout that kind of work, cheap though they are. The ideas of gathering resources and finding other survivors to assist on your journey, while not particularly well implemented, are also fairly sound.

The Final Verdict

For all its ambitions, The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct simply feels cheap and tawdry. It’s ugly, dull and thoroughly unenjoyable. It looks like we’re going to have to wait for Telltale’s next effort before we get a Walking Dead worth playing again.

The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct

Platform: PS3 / Xbox / PC
Developer: Terminal Reality
Similar to: The Walking Dead
 
Vote for this article Log in with Facebook

More Info on The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct

The Walking Dead FPS The Walking Dead FPS The Walking Dead FPS The Walking Dead FPS The Walking Dead FPS

The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct review Comments

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
Wii U is going to be a quality console (in Australia) if Activision continues to not release its shit games on it.
Sounds like they just took some sort of pre-done template and slapped some zombies on top of it.

Ben said: Wii U is going to be a quality console (in Australia) if Activision continues to not release its shit games on it.


called this months ago :P

Knew I would despise it after playing through Telltale's series. I think this was quickly put together to ride the success of the Telltale games. If you didn't play the game but heard "The Walking Dead" is amazing then it's not hard to think that this is a sequel and want ti buy it. Damn Activision.
Cha-Ching. Cha-Ching.
Saw this coming, the idea was nice though, but it was destined to be a flop. =/
Tano
+

ManicPanda said: Saw this coming, the idea was nice though, but it was destined to be a flop. =/



It's not a flop until it doesn't sell :P
And to think i was waiting for this game.First Dead Island then RE 6 and now this [sick]

Ghosty said: And to think i was waiting for this game.First Dead Island then RE 6 and now this


You can add Dead Space 3 to that list too. What happened to survival horror?

1wiierdguy said:

Ghosty said: And to think i was waiting for this game.First Dead Island then RE 6 and now this


You can add Dead Space 3 to that list too. What happened to survival horror?



Apparently nobody bought them.
wow could this be game of the year [Derp]

gammaray13 said: wow could this be game of the year



Most disappointing game of the year? Classic Activision game of the year? Shameful love game of the year?
Didn't really enjoy this game, I was hoping for more.

I would rate this as a 2/10

[Facepalm]
a very disappointing game, it didnt take long to complete.and felt repetitive ..the game would have been a lot better if it took a grand theft auto approach.... free roaming with different characters...the whole game feels rushed....i am a huge walking dead fan but this game does not do it any justice....1 out 5
If you would like some laughs, this game is for you.

Post a comment

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
  • The Walking Dead FPS
  • The Walking Dead FPS
  • The Walking Dead FPS
  • The Walking Dead FPS
  • The Walking Dead FPS
  • The Walking Dead: Survival InstinctThe Walking Dead: Survival Instinct Video
  • The Walking Dead: Survival InstinctThe Walking Dead: Survival Instinct Video
  • The Walking Dead: Survival InstinctThe Walking Dead: Survival Instinct Video

Recently Read

Featured Xbox 360 Content

Destiny beta - What do you think?

Destiny beta - What do you think?

21/07/2014 Polls 2 5
5 Reasons Conker’s Bad Fur Day was set up to fail

5 Reasons Conker’s Bad Fur Day was set up to fail

Gryllis 18 hours Articles 3 9
Lego Batman 3: Beyond Gotham trailer
Tano 18 hours News 0 3
Battlefield: Hardline story will visit 'Breaking Bad meth country'

Battlefield: Hardline story will visit 'Breaking Bad meth country'

Tano 1 day News 0 1
Friendly Fire Show 64: Nintendo 64 Special

Friendly Fire Show 64: Nintendo 64 Special

Podcast 1 day Articles 0 2
Destiny will have one location per planet

Destiny will have one location per planet

Tano 1 day News 2 3
Dark Souls 2: Crown of the Sunken King DLC review

Dark Souls 2: Crown of the Sunken King DLC review

PaulV 3 days Reviews 1 8
Remember co-op games being fun for being awful?

Remember co-op games being fun for being awful?

Jickle 3 days Articles 3 7
Win an exclusive spot in the Assassin's Creed Unity TV ad!

Win an exclusive spot in the Assassin's Creed Unity TV ad!

MMGN 3 days News 11 23

Community Content

My proudest individual achievement

My proudest individual achievement

3 days ago Blog 9 0

MMGN Updates

Status
Updating..
Username

stublu, Tano, RSOP commented on Firefly Online: Should we be excited or prepare for disappointment?

stublu 16 mins ago
Username

Olly , stonecold commented on Here's why you need to upgrade your version of The Last Of Us

Olly 57 mins ago
Username

commented on Favourite 2014 game so far?

Flyverson 13 hours ago
Username

Flyverson is now Level 2!

Flyverson 13 hours ago
Username

stevenhear is now Level 4!

stevenhear 13 hours ago
Username

commented on Mad Max: Fury Road - Comic-Con First Look

tsubibo 13 hours ago
Username

Flyverson got flower, Resogun, Blacklight Retribution, Strider and other 6 games

Flyverson 14 hours ago
Username

Flyverson just unlocked the The Collector achievement!

Flyverson 14 hours ago
Username

commented on Win Transformers: Rise Of The Dark Spark!

Macomb 15 hours ago