State of Decay: Year One Survival Edition review

by Nathan Misa Featured

10 Comments 16 Votes 32741 Views 24/04/2015 Back to Reviews

UPDATE: Xbox One version

State of Decay has been released as the "Year One Survival Edition" on Xbox One for $30. As we said on Xbox 360, it's one of the best zombie games we've ever played and this compilation is the best of the bunch in terms of content. It includes the main game, as well as Breakdown, the survival mode added post-launch, and Lifeline, the story-driven DLC.

Unlike the original release, there aren't any problems buying it in Australia. It's now openly for sale, after it was mildly censored to obtain an R18+ rating -- the Australian Classification Board really doesn't like drug use.

Aside from that, there's nothing special about the Xbox One re-release. It's bumped up to 1080p and resolves some of the texture issues of the Xbox 360 version, but this certainly isn't a remastering. It's a tweaked port, at best, and still suffers from some horrible framerate drops. Technically, it's no worse than the Xbox 360 version, but it's ugly for an Xbox One game. The reason to buy this version -- aside from being able to play on a current-gen platform -- is for all of the content in one place. There's over 50 hours of gameplay here, and the expansion expands upon the formula for the better. For $30 it's a great package, just be don't expect the faults of the Xbox 360 version to be addresses.

Original review (28/06/2013)

Zombies are invading video games at an exponential rate these days. No longer restricted to the realm of cheesy B-grade horror flicks, the undead hordes are now mainstream and are, in all honesty, getting a bit out of hand, shambling into every second film, FPS or open-world title like... well, a plague. And now, they just aren’t as scary.

Thankfully, State of Decay isn’t your average zombie game. It puts those undead bastards to work to re-create the tense, suspenseful survival-horror gameplay we originally associated flesh-eating walking corpses with. The end result is an ambitious, content-packed Xbox Live Arcade game you can pay and play for just 1600MSP ($20) — though a little trick is required for us poor Aussies to get it.

State of Decay consolidates all that is great about the zombie apocalypse scenario and offers survival nuts everything they secretly dream of — gathering supplies, building a fort, establishing a community, culling the hordes with smarts and generally conquering Armageddon — and backs its ambitious ideas up with dynamic choices, actual consequences and solid gameplay mechanics, all with a surprising amount of depth.

It’s a shame, then, that the game is slightly let down by technical problems. It’s even more of a shame (and a joke) that our country’s classification board has opted to refuse classification for what is the XBLA game to own this year for in-game drug references, delaying its release. Quick, hand me the bong to get over this unnecessary BS.

State of Decay immediately throws players into the deep-end as Marcus, a store-clerk and experienced outdoorsman who finds himself returning to a small town engulfed by chaos after a hiking trip with his friend, Ed. The two stumble upon an off-duty military survivor, Maya, and witness the massacre of several others.

The trio eventually find refuge with another group of survivors at the town’s church, who have built a base and survived through a mess that doesn’t seem any closer to ending. It is here you’re introduced to the central theme of the game: never let your guard down.

Switching between Marcus and Maya in the beginning (and any other able-bodied survivor who you raise to friend status) via third-person perspective, players are tasked to manage and fortify a survivor community, scavenge a myriad of necessary supplies — ammo, construction tools, food, fuel, and medicine — and deal with the ever-increasing amount of threats and problems which can bring down the community.

And that’s just the problems associated with the human element.

Zombies in State of Decay are not drastically frightening or different in their traditional depictions. It's how you engage them which makes the experience so tense and exciting. This isn’t Dead Island or Left 4 Dead where you can mow or chop hordes down with little effort: sure, one or two zeds are easy enough to bash to death, but if a group rushes you, run your ass off and live to fight another day.

The zombies are an actual challenge, and therefore a threat. When you triumph over their superior numbers and nasty bite, it's immensely satisfying, more so than killing hundreds in Dead Island by yourself. It's also just as crushing when they overwhelm you — which may happen a lot.

It is here you’re introduced to the central theme of the game: never let your guard down."

Why? In State of Decay, you aren’t a bad-ass zombie killer — at least, not until you train and level up. You’re a real person, a survivor stuck in a big mess who needs to think about every decision carefully, especially considering there’s only one save file and you can’t be cheap and reload a checkpoint. The game remembers every action: player character death is permanent, so if you die out there, say goodbye to that character's story. If you don’t have any other survivors to switch perspective to, it’s game over.

You can shoot that zombie for a faster kill or drive to get places faster, but be prepared to attract a horde to the noise and waste valuable resources. You can also avoid the hordes rather than fight, but if you don’t cull enough of them over time, it can cause real problems in the future. Getting caught off-guard by more than two or three zombies is a recipe for disaster, with no second chances.

The same problems apply within the survivor community. You need to constantly make sure all supplies are well-stocked via consistent scavenging, make sure morale remains high with fellow survivors by paying attention to their needs, and micro-manage your multiple playable characters to ensure they’re well-rested and not overused. Characters get fatigued, and you'll learn your cardio meter is everything in this game, even more important than health. Running and carrying supplies back to base sucks the energy out of your guys, so be wary and either raise your stats or switch survivors.

You'll also need to fortify your base and upgrade its areas for more efficiency —more beds equals more rest, a better medical bay equals more people available for labour, a training areas equals tougher fighters, etc — to level up your playable survivors and ensure the NPCs at home-base are beefed up for defending your home.

Most missions will be randomised depending on your immediate needs after the initial introductory hours. If you don't attend to them, or if you don't have enough Influence — a meter which measures your level of control as leader, gained via missions and contributing supplies — your mini-society will collapse quickly.

Expansion is eventually necessary via the main storyline and general gameplay. You'll be hard-pressed to establish outposts and other bases all around the sizable open-world while maintaining your HQ once the immediate area starts to get scarce on resources. Scout out bases with formidable walls or other natural barriers to maximise your chances of survival and allow your guys time to train up and truly become zombie-hunters.

State of Decay makes what seems a mundane task such as hauling your backpack back to camp or driving fellow survivors around the neighbourhood to scout base locations a constantly engaging experience. Depending on the survivor you use, different dialogue triggers and changes will be apparent during the mission, increasing potential replay-ability.

Melee combat is the most effective way of dispatching ghouls. You'll find a variety of home-made, make-shift blunt and edged weapons to bash skulls in with, and sneaking up on one or two zombies with a one-hit kill sneak move is the safest way to move forward. Guns are devastatingly powerful, as they should be, but ammo is scarce — sometimes not because the game-world doesn't have enough, but because leaving plenty back home increases your Influence, and taking too much for scavenge runs lowers it. This adds another tactical element to managing your community and leadership within it.

Perhaps one of the best features of the game is how it keeps going even after you switch it off. You’ll find the dynamic world has moved on in your absence, and upon returning, if you left your survivors with low morale, zero barricades or not enough resources, the game will update you on how they fared. Be prepared to deal with utter disaster if you neglected your homies.

It's impossible to detail every mechanic and option available to you because there's just so much to discover out there, and that's what makes the game so epic: it's the ultimate zombie-survival-management title we've been waiting for, if a little rough around the edges in its technical aspects.

This isn’t Dead Island or Left 4 Dead where you can mow or chop hordes down with little effort: sure, one or two zeds are easy enough to bash to death, but if a group rushes you, run your ass off and live to fight another day.

There is also a story located within State of Decay and for an Xbox Live Arcade game, it's great to see the narrative and quality of voice-acting was paid so much attention to, even with the focus being on the survival-management mechanics. Starting protagonists Marcus and Maya are interesting characters you can relate to with their own quirks and motivations, and playing as them and aiding their ascension to reluctant but natural leaders is enjoyable.

There are several other fixed and randomised survivors you take control of along the way, and you can choose to play the story as them. Or you can even miss out on their individual contributions if they fall prey to death, making every potential playthrough unique.

What hampers the addictive survival-management gameplay is a jittery game engine and some visual stumbles. I experienced a terrible frame-rate in areas with more than a few zombies and some clipping issues. Melee combat can also be a bit jarring, but bashing and blasting zombie skulls is just so satisfying, you'll hardly notice. The character models, lip-syncing and environment are also not as detailed as your average game, but considering the size of the game-world, the deep mechanics, and the fact that it's an XBLA title, Undead Labs should still be commended.

As the game chugged on and the depth of its mechanics opened up, these graphical and technical issues became less evident, if only because I was more focused on outrunning my possible death. The only slight disappointment I had was my anticipation to fight against other, hostile survivors (gathered from hours of mistrusting our bastard species in The Last of Us), but alas: State of Decay focuses on, for now, human on zombie violence.

The Final Verdict

State of Decay is the ultimate zombie-survival package. It's ambitious and immersive, the gameplay mechanics are deep and the choices you make dynamic, and its game world expansive and reactive, replicating the zombie-apocalypse survival in a remote small-town region perfectly, tailoring your group's fate to your choices, successes and failures.

While the game engine suffers from bugs, the solid and addictive gameplay more than makes up for it. Undead Labs are using their game to test the waters for a bigger, better zombie-survival MMO, and after playing State of Decay, I can't wait to see what's ahead.

State of Decay Year One Survival Edition

Got Right
  • + Dynamic and expansive open-world
  • + Heaps of content for $30 on Xbox One
  • + Zombies are actually a challenge
Got Wrong
  • - Still has frame rate issues on Xbox One
  • - Clipping issues
  • - Leaving too long can cause many headaches when you boot it up again
Platform: Xbox / XboxOne
Vote for this article Log in with Facebook

State of Decay: Year One Survival Edition review Comments

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
Isnt it banned in Australia?
Man, this sounds amazing. Might have to try the workaround to get it working here.
You can't stop us, classification board!

Gryllis said: You can't stop us, classification board!

Quiver to the might of the MMGN editorial team
Loved every minute of playing and reviewing it for MMGN. Ef' tha po-leece.
Ebay here i come.
I've said it once and Ill say it again- fire Ned Flanders off the classification Board.....diddly.
Any chance the banning pushed the quick review :D
Looks cool! I gotta try this one right away. I've been bored for a while. I need something to obsess over lol :D

Linnea Ten, Gamer
Oh zombie. Like a Rs evil version.

Post a comment

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook

Recently Read

Featured Xbox 360 Content

GOTY 2015: Best Game Of 2015

GOTY 2015: Best Game Of 2015

22/12/2015 Polls 18 15
Friendly Fire Show 122: The Finale

Friendly Fire Show 122: The Finale

Podcast 21/03 Articles 25 6
Friendly Fire Show 121's The Divided
Podcast 15/03 Articles 13 3 in 2016 - Why there is no new content in 2016 - Why there is no new content

MMGN 14/03 News 37 21
Australian game sales approach $3b, mostly digital
maxiboy 13/03 News 19 11
Target store in SA displays games in plain packaging

Target store in SA displays games in plain packaging

maxiboy 13/03 News 12 12
Friendly Fire Show 120: I swear, by the Sun and Moon...
Podcast 02/03 Articles 12 1
Friendly Fire Show 119: Weekend at Tano's

Friendly Fire Show 119: Weekend at Tano's

Podcast 23/02 Articles 10 1
Friendly Fire Show 118: R.I.P. Tano

Friendly Fire Show 118: R.I.P. Tano

Podcast 11/02 Articles 8 4

Community Content

Fallout-themed excuses to get the day off

Fallout-themed excuses to get the day off

09/11/2015 Blog 31 0

MMGN Updates


kkuch is now Level 10!

kkuch 23 mins ago

pabebe23 is now Level 4!

pabebe23 44 mins ago

kkuch is now Level 9!

kkuch 51 mins ago

kkuch is now Level 8!

kkuch 1 hour ago

kkuch is now Level 7!

kkuch 1 hour ago

kkuch is now Level 6!

kkuch 1 hour ago

kkuch is now Level 5!

kkuch 1 hour ago

kkuch is now Level 4!

kkuch 1 hour ago

kkuch is now Level 3!

kkuch 1 hour ago

kkuch is now Level 2!

kkuch 1 hour ago