The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings Enhanced Edition Review

by Nathan Misa Featured

11 Comments 28 Votes 1937 Views 16/04/2012 Back to Reviews

The Xbox 360 goes White Wolf.

The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings Enhanced Edition is just what every Xbox 360 gamer and RPG fanatic could ever dream of. The 2011 smash hit makes its way to the 360 with a redesigned interface, improved controls and combat, optimised engine for the console and four hours of new gameplay experiences, as well as a new intro cinematic.

What The Witcher 2 Got Right

Narrative and Maturity - The Witcher 2’s darker and more adult-driven narrative quickly establishes to new players to the series that although the game is set in a fantasy setting, people are people. There is no sugar-coating the violent, questionable and dark things Temeria’s citizens say or act, or what its history entails.

The Witcher 2 is a game that expects you to care, to be aware and proactive in the actions you may lead Geralt of Rivia to make and the subsequent consequences which will shape the future of Temeria. Make no mistake; this is an adult’s game, one where you have to be smart. You cannot simply expect to progress without actively involving yourself in the complex tale of sex, lies and violence you are about to shape as Geralt. The game involves you, makes everything from the conversations to the exploration riveting and interactive. You define his story, not the writers.

Get the Adobe Flash Player to see this video.

Complexity in choices and dynamic quests - The Witcher 2 is a RPG and as to be expected, it is heavy on the dialogue and choice. The conversation system in The Witcher 2 is evidently morally gray; there are no clearly defined good or evil choices laid out for the player. When there seems to be, there is more often than not a surprise or twist on the other side. Dialogue options usually consist of two or three quick summaries as to what Geralt might say or think depending on the player’s interests or motivations. Many of the action sequences and main narrative cutscenes have a timer and so the player is forced to quickly react to a situation or conversation presented to them, adding a nice touch of intensity and urgency to the atmosphere of each moment.

From the central, intriguing plot of regicide and identity to the side-plots of murder investigations, monster-hunting and missing-persons, The Witcher 2 has a myriad of quests for the player to immerse and involve themselves in, all with several branching choices and varying outcomes and consequences.

One prominent example is a side-quest early on that involves an Elf woman surrounded by violent and racist town guards accusing her of leading two other militia soldiers to their deaths. The Elf insists she is innocent but the human soldiers of Flotsam, who are well-known for their racial hatred for the Elves and the rebel Scoia'tael, give her no confidence.

The situation can be avoided altogether by the player, but if interrupted, the player is presented with a series of morally-vague options. You can inquire about the overall situation and ignore the woman’s argument in favour of the pressing main quest (and thus guarantee the woman’s imminent execution and termination of the questline), or potentially get involved and convince the guards you can prove she was not linked with the bodies by investigation. Afterwards, the player can accuse her of being a guerrilla, or choose to listen to her explanation once more.

Although it may seem morally right to get involved and help prove and believe her innocence, the quest and its instigators promptly shake their fantasy stereotypes and shove any feeling of moral superiority in your face.

The path The Witcher 2 takes is more of a simple one; usually what you see isn’t what you get, and it is up to you to decide if getting involved or influencing another person or group is truly benefiting Geralt, or anyone for that matter, rather than a broader consideration of what is right or wrong.

Customisation and combat - The Enhanced Edition gives an information heavy tutorial at the beginning of the game detailing the easy-to-use control interface, combat system, and properties of alchemy, side-weapons and armour. The amount of potions, crafting and upgrade combinations for armour and weapons that are available for customisation is impressive. The extensive character development tree also gives players the freedom to choose which talents - magic, combat or alchemy - their Geralt specialises and excels in, rather than being forced to follow a predetermined path.

Combat in The Witcher 2 is fluid and dynamic with every swing of the sword violent and weighty, and every cast of magic tactical and meaningful. Geralt can hack, slash, parry and riposte against a variety of enemies, using the elements of steel and silver and the fighting styles of agile or heavy to defeat each unique enemy. He can also take down several enemies with lethal finishing moves, adding flair, diversity and strategy to each battle. The fast-paced movement across the battlefield make the combat hectic and challenging, but extremely satisfying.

Geralt can also cast a range of spells -- such as Igni, an offensive fireball and Yrden, a magical trap -- with the touch of a button, shaking up any combat situation. A radial menu contains all magic signs, spells, bombs and traps which can be easily accessed during combat, slowing time stylishly until you make your choice and re-enter the fray.

Lore - The Witcher 2 has an impressive codex of information for all those interested in the universe of the game. The Codex contains most of the game’s lore, characters, items, mission progress and so on. All of it is told and presented in an amusing and unique first-person account of one of Geralt’s main NPC allies who is more informed of the world and its aspects than Geralt, giving both a humorous but plot-logical reason for having such knowledge available rather than an omniscient or detached source. It all adds up to make an endearing and unique touch to the game’s fantasy setting.

Transition from PC to Xbox 360 - CD Projekt Red should be commended for the absolutely brilliant job they have done in the transition from the PC to the Xbox 360. The Witcher 2 isn’t just another cash-in port- the fact that they have added more content and extra cinematic sequences makes that clear from the beginning. But the more time spent with the game, the more apparent it is that the developer optimised its engine to the fullest for the 360’s specs.

The graphics look superb and polished to a level many might not expect possible on the 360. The 360 version also carries a different lighting and art style which results in environments and the characters inhabiting them looking more natural and realistic than the unnatural illumination Geralt and the main characters seemed to have in the original PC release.

What The Witcher 2 Got Wrong

Minor technical compromises - The game looks and runs great for the most part, but there is the occasional stutter, frame-rate drop and texture pop-in, with the latter particularly prominent in a few early main-quest cutscenes. These problems can be significantly lessened when the game is installed to the Xbox 360 hard drive.

Poor voice acting and dialogue - A few characters such as Triss Merigold suffer from miss-matched voice actors and bland and poorly-acted out dialogue, and many NPCs share the same voice actor (and character model), particularly the thugs and drunks of Flotsam. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing, but it does break the immersion from time to time.

Final Verdict

The Witcher 2 is ultimately one of the most satisfying RPG experiences to ever grace the Xbox 360. Its deep and riveting fantasy tale will immerse and challenge players with its complex choices, impressive visuals and visceral combat system. It is very nonlinear and choice-driven and as such would not appeal to a gamer who does not like investing in heavy narrative and non-linear direction, nor would it appeal to those who simply wish or expect to explore everywhere geographically due to its smaller but more organised world structure in comparison to free-roaming RPG titles like Skyrim. But for the hardcore RPG fanatics, loot hoarders and monster-hunting enthusiasts, The Witcher 2 will stand out as one of the Xbox 360’s best RPG titles available.

By Nathan Misa

The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings Review

9.5
Unemployment Pixel Master Editor's Choice Golden Globe
Platform: Xbox / PC
Developer: CD Projekt RED
Similar to: The Witcher, LOTR: War in the North
Vote for this article Log in with Facebook

More Info on The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings

The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings
The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings Australian Release: Out Now

The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings Enhanced Edition Review Comments

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
RSOP
+
Nice review, have to check out the series


Check the rack on this babe :P
laying on the thick bs

the best rpgs on the system are blue dragon, lost oddessy, fallout 3

stealth20k said: laying on the thick bs
the best rpgs on the system are blue dragon, lost oddessy, fallout 3



GTFO

The Witcher series is amazing i love the mature tone and want more of it, i'm glad it's coming to 360 but i'll be sticking to my PC copy.

By the way great review :)

stealth20k said: laying on the thick bs
the best rpgs on the system are blue dragon, lost oddessy, fallout 3



I personally think if I had to rank some RPG titles, that Tales of Vesperia and (now) The Witcher 2 are the deepest and most satisfying RPG choices available on the 360. Dark Souls is a very close third, Skyrim fourth, and, from what I have experienced, Lost Oddysey would probably be fifth (I haven't finished all 4 discs yet but the story-line and cinematics are really good).

The Witcher 2 stands out from all of them, though, because of its maturity and broad depth of the narrative and its vast choices. The choices you make (or don't), and the wins and loses you incur actually influence and change the story and characters of the game in so many significant ways, and not just on a superficial level. There were some really cool quests that shocked me as to the level of influence you could have on the story and outcome. And being an avid RPG fan, 16 endings and two major (and substantial) diverting story-lines makes it kind of, well, awesome. I'm a sucker for storyline, as you can tell.

Dicky said:The Witcher series is amazing i love the mature tone and want more of it, i'm glad it's coming to 360 but i'll be sticking to my PC copy.
By the way great review



Thanks mate!
Does anybody know if they censored this for australia?

Skelerax said: Does anybody know if they censored this for australia?


no its not, awesome review and should have been game of the year way better than skyrim

Skelerax said: Does anybody know if they censored this for australia?



The PAL-UK version I received for the review was uncensored. There was an interview with CD Projekt RED's Lead Combat Designer Maciej Szczesnik, and they asked him a question about censorship to which Szczesnik stated there was no deletion or censorship of nudity or violence in the Xbox 360 edition. www.rpgamer.com/...

gammaray13 said: no its not, awesome review and should have been game of the year way better than skyrim



Thanks mate. I really like Skyrim but ultimately I place The Witcher 2 a little higher because of the better story-line and impact of player choices.
Actually it has been changed for us,
www.atomicmpc.com.au/...
I don't care how minute the changes were I'll not stand for this pedantry, coming soon to Europe... my money.
Oh wow, that is really disappointing to have it confirmed. That's just like the case of the original PC release so I guess people were always wondering about it. It's just two quests though, I don't understand the point of its censorship. Our classification system is broken.
Small typo in the 'similar to' section below the score :P

RSOP said: Nice review, have to check out the series

Check the rack on this babe


She's a prostitute, she's supposed to have a rack. =_=

Nice review. I'm hoping this game skyrockets in sales (due to the gaming drought right now) and grows more popular, it deserves it. ^_^


Tyrus said:

stealth20k said: laying on the thick bs
the best rpgs on the system are blue dragon, lost oddessy, fallout 3


I personally think if I had to rank some RPG titles, that Tales of Vesperia and (now) The Witcher 2 are the deepest and most satisfying RPG choices available on the 360. Dark Souls is a very close third, Skyrim fourth, and, from what I have experienced, Lost Oddysey would probably be fifth (I haven't finished all 4 discs yet but the story-line and cinematics are really good).



I don't think you can compare them, you can fully enjoy Skyrim without touching the story. The Witcher (2), on the other hand, wouldn't be anywhere near as awesome without its storyline. X_X

Post a comment

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
  • The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings
  • The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings
  • The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings
  • The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings
  • The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings
  • The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings
  • The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings
  • The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings
  • The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings
  • The Witcher 2: Assassins of KingsThe Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings Video
  • The Witcher 2: Assassins of KingsThe Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings Video

Recently Read

Featured Xbox 360 Content

Best Xbox 360 Exclusive Of All-Time

Best Xbox 360 Exclusive Of All-Time

06/05/2013 Polls 34 64
Games piracy isn't as bad as we thought

Games piracy isn't as bad as we thought

Gryllis 1 hour News 0 9
The best comments on MMGN this week, Volume 5

The best comments on MMGN this week, Volume 5

Tano 2 hours News 6 12
Deathstroke is playable in Batman: Arkham Origins

Deathstroke is playable in Batman: Arkham Origins

Tyrus 3 hours News 1 1
Gears of War: Judgment 'Lost Relics' multiplayer DLC set for June
Tyrus 3 hours News 0 0
Kevin Conroy returns for Batman: Arkham Origins

Kevin Conroy returns for Batman: Arkham Origins

Tyrus 4 hours News 2 3
GRID 2 gameplay trailer brings back the Tokyo drift

GRID 2 gameplay trailer brings back the Tokyo drift

Tyrus 22 hours News 0 7
We will become a generation of cross-gamers

We will become a generation of cross-gamers

Gryllis 2 days Articles 13 17
Fuse preview: 2 hours with Insomniac's latest

Fuse preview: 2 hours with Insomniac's latest

Tano 3 days Articles 1 10

Community Content

Merchandise - Stuff for consumers you can actually purchase this time!

Merchandise - Stuff for consumers you can actually purchase this time!

16 hours ago Blog 0 0

MMGN Updates

Status
Updating..
Username

Tano, Azza, Milky and other 2 users commented on The best comments on MMGN this week, Volume 5

Tano 1 min ago
Username

Aoi is now Level 26!

Aoi 4 mins ago
Username

Milky, Tano commented on Next Xbox reveal

Milky 30 mins ago
Username

commented on We will become a generation of cross-gamers

Gryllis 48 mins ago
Username

maxiboy, RSOP commented on Ouya to camp out in E3's carpark

maxiboy 57 mins ago
Username

commented on Deathstroke is playable in Batman: Arkham Origins

Matteh 1 hour ago
Username

Gryllis added a photo - How did THQ go broke with this E3 strategy?

Gryllis 1 hour ago
Username

Tano, Gryllis commented on Kevin Conroy returns for Batman: Arkham Origins

Tano 3 hours ago
Username

commented on Nintendo has lost E3 already?

Gryllis 3 hours ago