What's Wrong With NBA Live?

by Gaetano Prestia Featured 3 Comments 13 Votes 9220 Views 28/09/2012 Back to Articles

NBA Live 13 is dead and buried. It was probably never fully alive to begin with, although EA Sports had us thinking otherwise with trailers, previews and other updates leading into its rumoured late-October digital release, before its cancellation earlier today.

So what exactly has happened to this once respected and immensely popular sports sim? Was 2K Sports’ NBA 2K series really responsible for the series’ demise, or is it more than that? Did fans lose patience? Or did people just stop caring about basketball video games?

These are questions I’m asking myself, because I care deeply about this franchise: growing up in the Michael Jordan era, the NBA Live series was my chance to replicate the superstardom that is the NBA. For the past few years I’ve been able to sit back and admit that the NBA 2K series is probably better overall, but I can’t admit that NBA Live should follow suit. I never really wanted the series to change that much, as long as I got an enjoyable basketball game that challenged me at the highest level and kept me playing through the season.

Get the Adobe Flash Player to see this video.

Yet, EA Sports doesn’t feel that NBA Live 13 is good enough to be released. I admire the decision to cancel it so close to release, because I don’t think doing that could be any worse that releasing a crappy game that no one cares for.

But questions remain: why promote a game (as modestly as EA Sports did) and then cancel it right before the season starts? The same mistake was made with NBA Elite 11: a demo was released and a release date set, but the game was cancelled (and rightfully so: the demo is disgracefully awful in every sense) literally weeks before it was released. How can consumer trust be restored?

As an NBA Live fan, frustrations have existed for a while. NBA Live 06 on Xbox 360 was a true insult to fans: it lacked any deep features and was basically just a visual demo for the console and EA Sports development tech. Compared to the team’s other offering at the time in Fight Night Round 3, NBA Live 06’s retail release was basically a demo on a disc.

The releases over the following years were met poorly from gamers and critics alike, as the 2K series continued to evolve the genre, offering new ways to interact with your virtual teammates. NBA Live kept the core experience intact, but NBA Elite’s dysfunctional button mapping and control issues showcased EA’s interest in replicating the successful mechanics of its competition, rather than offering its fans a genuine upgrade to a much-loved basketball gaming experience.

Were sales so bad that EA Sports needed to completely redefine the series? The change from NBA Live 10 to Elite 11’s demo is quite surreal, with the former feeling nothing, NOTHING, like the series it was supposed to be a spiritual successor to.

Interestingly, EA Sports’ commentary on the cancellation of NBA Live 13 is eerily similar to the statement we got about NBA Elite 11.

The publisher at the time said it wanted to create “a game that will introduce several breakthrough features”, and because that hadn’t been achieved, the game was eventually delayed and then cancelled. “Unfortunately, NBA ELITE 11 is not yet ready,” it said.

Similar rhetoric appears in the company’s statement for NBA Live 13’s cancellation. Terms like “innovation”, “quality” and “not ready” replicate a belief that the publisher doesn’t quite seem to have much faith in the NBA Live audience.

While gamers are thankfully getting the better of the two franchises with NBA 2K13, competition is a great thing that we should hope returns to the basketball sim genre. EA Sports certainly needs to get its act together, and instead of trying to reinvent the wheel, maybe it should take what was so loved about the series and expand on it. Because with its last two attempts at taking on 2K Sports’ apparent innovation with its own series, it’s creating games with no hype, no real drive and no NBA Live feel.

By Gaetano Prestia

Link to us http://360.mmgn.com/Articles/nba-live-y-u-so-sucky
Vote for this article Log in with Facebook

What's Wrong With NBA Live? Comments

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
If EA Sports wants to win me back (into the NBA LIVE series) they had better bring more than their A game.
They probably can't develop a true NBA game because all their focus, money & development teams are put into the FIFA franchise.
I remember before EA turned shit NBA Live was freaking awesome.
Since the changes made within EA, I don't think they have really won any real fans outside the FIFA domain.
I do hope they get their shit together and bring the NBA LIVE action that I used to love to much.

Diagonis83 said: If EA Sports wants to win me back (into the NBA LIVE series) they had better bring more than their A game.
They probably can't develop a true NBA game because all their focus, money & development teams are put into the FIFA franchise.
I remember before EA turned shit NBA Live was freaking awesome.
Since the changes made within EA, I don't think they have really won any real fans outside the FIFA domain.
I do hope they get their shit together and bring the NBA LIVE action that I used to love to much.



I think that basketball games have changed the most this generation. Football games are basically the same in terms of basic controls, and it's playable in that capacity without using the skills etc. and other new features that have been introduced since 2005, while basketball games need to be punishing, need to call fouls, need to go hot and cold, because of the pace and frequency of score attempts. It doesn't seem like EA Sports can nail that without straight out copying 2K. How can NBA Live 13 be so bad that you can't release it, when the last NBA game was NBA Elite 11 (2010 development)? That means all of 2011 and 2012 so far really SHOULD have been committed to the game. Either it was, and the team was so crap that it couldn't make a good game, or EA thought it would start development late, promote it, but never really intend to ship it, generate hype and then say, "Here is NBA Live 14", a game with 2 years development under its belt, and probably some curious gamers, especially if it's next-gen. Nice marketing? :P
I was looking forward to seeing what this game would be like. IF they want to compete with 2K they need to have really good graphics, amazing physics and something new/innovative that 2K hasnt done.

Each year they 'delay' or simply dont release a game gives 2K a larger monopoly in basketball games.

Post a comment

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook

Recently Read

Featured Xbox 360 Content

Most Anticipated September Game

Most Anticipated September Game

6 days ago Polls 2 8
The Phantom Pain dog companion: How to unlock

The Phantom Pain dog companion: How to unlock

Tano 16 hours News 1 4
The Phantom Pain Mother Base Upgrade Guide

The Phantom Pain Mother Base Upgrade Guide

Tano 18 hours Articles 2 3
The Phantom Pain microtransaction pricing revealed

The Phantom Pain microtransaction pricing revealed

Tano 22 hours News 0 6
The Phantom Pain day-one patch adds multiplayer support

The Phantom Pain day-one patch adds multiplayer support

Tano 23 hours News 5 4
Ground Zeroes update ties into The Phantom Pain

Ground Zeroes update ties into The Phantom Pain

Tano 23 hours News 0 4
The Taken King won't launch with a raid

The Taken King won't launch with a raid

Tano 1 day News 1 1
Massive Destiny update incoming for The Taken King

Massive Destiny update incoming for The Taken King

Tano 1 day News 4 2
Disney Infinity 3.0 + Twilight of the Republic review

Disney Infinity 3.0 + Twilight of the Republic review

Gryllis 4 days Reviews 2 4

Community Content

What's it really like going to E3?

What's it really like going to E3?

12/06/2015 Blog 5 0

MMGN Updates

Status
Updating..
Username

barters81, Mobe1969 commented on Gaming will be a major focus of Apple TV 4 - report

barters81 7 mins ago
Username

Skiparoo is now Level 2!

Skiparoo 10 hours ago
Username

commented on Gaming will be a major focus of Apple TV 4 - report

chucky110 10 hours ago
Username

Sesshy is now Level 4!

Sesshy 10 hours ago
Username

Skiparoo just unlocked the Welcomed achievement!

Skiparoo 16 hours ago
Username

Marshal976, Matrix6, maxiboy commented on Deus Ex: Mankind Divided release date announced, desperately wants pre-orders

Marshal976 18 hours ago