Has Kinect failed gamers?

by Nathan Misa Featured 15 Comments 30 Votes 2279 Views 24/07/2012 Back to Articles

It's been roughly one and a half years since Kinect launched worldwide in late 2010, selling over 8 million units in its first 60 days and making the Guiness World Book of Records for being the "fastest selling consumer electronics device" ever.

Since then, the motion-sensing device has sold over 18 million units as of January 2012. It's safe to say from a financial and commercial standpoint, the device was a success as a product, and has no doubt helped prolong the life-span of the Xbox 360 and helped Microsoft sell millions more consoles.

But what else has Kinect notably accomplished or changed other than impressive sales? In my opinion, not much.

Let me elaborate; when I ask what Kinect has notably accomplished or changed, I mean in relation to "core" gamers; the massive market who owned an Xbox 360 console before the Kinect came along, the people who were probably not all "casual" gamers, whatever these two interchangeable terms mean these days. Has it provided for "core" gamers?

Kinect's purpose and functionality is for a gaming console, so it was pretty safe for me and others to assume the device would have some sort of appeal for all gamers and be used primarily in a gameplay manner. After all, Microsoft hyped up the launch as something that would revolutionise gaming and provide great games for both the "hardcore" and people who traditionally never play the games the Xbox 360 is well known for, such as Halo or Gears. They wanted to expand the market and provide something new at the same time, and that was understandable, even if it was obvious Microsoft were desperate for the market the Wii had captured.

The potential and technology was there for innovative features to be implemented, beyond the stuff we've seen before like voice-chat and voice commands (as nifty as they are) or fun (but overly simple) motion games involving Fruit and Ninjas. Kinect's competitor, the Wii Motion controls, may have seemed gimmicky to me initially, but while there was a heavy amount of shovelware, Nintendo utilised motion creatively with quality first-party "hardcore" games. MS had the perfect opportunity to improve upon Nintendo's shortcomings in the motion-sensing gaming market with its own first-party offerings and really show off its capabilities to third-party developers and get us gamers some great games.

But no, they didn't. I realised this too late when I fell for the Project Natal hype towards the hardcore, and bought a Kinect close to its launch in 2010. I've tried to play and enjoy a lot of its gaming library since then, with an open-mind to try new experiences. But it saddens me to conclude there is practically nothing to be genuinely excited for in relation to Kinect, even if you're a gamer who likes to play games like Dance Central, Kinect Star Wars or Kinect Sports. But even these games, dubbed "casual" by some, are unresponsive and average at the best of times.

It's hard to be open-minded with Kinect, whether you're a "casual" or "hardcore" gamer, when there is such a limited range of variety available, let alone games that really use Kinect to the fullest advantage, creatively and effectively. Right now the market is full of fitness and sport games, sub-par on-rails experiences and "hardcore games" that merely use Kinect as a minor feature, such as Skyrim and Mass Effect 3's voice capabilities. The only notable exception that comes to my mind would be the Gunstringer, which was both fun and accurate enough in its Kinect implementation, a rarity in the game released thus far.

There is also nothing noteworthy to boast about Kinect in relation to its software or technical capabilities. Playing Fighter's Uncaged, a game which arguably tried to boast it's "hardcore" factor in the form of a supposedly brutal underground brawler, illustrated and highlighted the device's saddening technical shortcomings. The response time to a player's movements, punches and kicks is horrendous. Worst of all, the game only accounts for a strictly limited moveset, so you can't pull off your own uppercuts or spin kicks. Since Microsoft markets the Kinect by boasting "with Kinect, you are the controller", it doesn't make sense that I can't fight the way I want to within the game, and being limited to only a few basic movements is quite disappointing.

Since Microsoft markets the Kinect by boasting "with Kinect, you are the controller", it doesn't make sense that I can't fight the way I want to within the game, and being limited to only a few basic movements is quite disappointing."

Microsoft have attempted to facilitate creative experiences like Rise of Nightmares, Diabolical Pitch, Star Wars Kinect and Steel Batallion: Heavy Armour, but all have failed out of a combination of terrible marketing and the mostly unresponsive and gimmicky way Kinect's controls were handled within.

Steel Batallion: Heavy Armour in particular was perhaps the biggest disappointment for me in regards to Kinect; the storyline premise, the hyrbid use of the Xbox 360 controller and Kinect and all the franchise's history seemed like it would be Kinect's first big hit, but Capcom's boast about the game being the most accurate Kinect game yet was for nought, with the game being critically panned.

In my experience with it, the game constantly asked me to recalibrate the Kinect, constantly misread my gestures and caused me to die or fail in frustration when it did not respond to my movements correctly or in time. The few missions I did get through, many felt so gimmicky (such as standing up without moving for several minutes to wait for your target to appear) that I just gave up on trying to be open-minded and went back to my traditional controller-based games. I understand there was always going to be a delay in response time, but the accuracy of the device really has crippled what could have been a very different and very enjoyable gaming experience.

And that's exactly the problem. I haven't touched my Kinect since because of such a terrible gaming experience, save for when I need to comically abuse players on Gears of War 3 after a heated match. Most Kinect games I've played feel like a chore to do so or don't respond or react well with the motion sensor at all, and there's no true incentive for me to use it when playing Skyrim, unless I want to wake the neighbours up with Dragonborn shouts. Just like the Wii, the novelty wore off, ableit a lot faster for me. People buy it, play it for a bit, then never touch it again.

Kinect's failure in providing gamers with quality first-party Kinect titles is also reflected in the fact that only one of Microsoft's big three exclusive franchises (Halo, Gears and Fable) are being made to really use Kinect (Fable: The Journey). Gears of War: Exile was quickly and quietly cancelled last year, no doubt due to uncertainties on Epic Games's part, and thus another set of massive gaming opportunities was missed. Not to mention Kinect's visibility in this year's E3 compared to last year's shows a little less confidence on the device than before.

I just can't help but wonder where Kinect's place is after nearly two years on the market, and can't help but feel it was a poor investment. Whether it simply needs more time on the market, or a technical revision to make it more successful with gamers and developers, I'd welcome any effort to see the device reach the innovation many know it can reach and the potential and recognition it truly deserves.

But this is just my opinion; what do you think about Kinect at this point in time? Do you feel it has a place for gamers beyond a video and voice-chat tool and typical on-rails experiences?

By Nathan Misa- Bio

Link to us http://360.mmgn.com/Articles/has-kinect-failed-gamers
Vote for this article Log in with Facebook

Has Kinect failed gamers? Comments

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
It was marketed at the Wii crowd, which is arguably not what we call "gamers".

I have hardly used it. In fact, it's not even plugged in, but I kind of like some of the voice sensor features that are optional. As long as they're not required, I'm cool with it.
Yeah, I get that it was primarily marketed to the Wii/motion-interested casual crowd, but there was always a lot of talk on Microsoft's part that there were going to be Kinect games that would provide for everyone. Somewhat foolishly, I think I led myself to believe there would be at least a few games which accomplished this "core" and "casual" balance by now.

I had looked forward to Crimson Dragon, Rise of Nightmares and Steel Batallion. But now that the latter two were sub-par from my play-time with them, I'm not too excited anymore about the remaining releases on schedule.
The idea had potential but it felt like it was only 'half there' when it was released. It needed to be a full experience from the beginning, we are only now beginning to see some mildly useful features, but it's too late because gamers that went out on a limb to buy it have either sold or given up on it already.
Yes, Kinect is the worst thing ever to come out of Microsoft. It doesn't work. Any self-respecting consumer should have returned it to the store.
Yes it has.

If kinect is Microsoft's focus from the start next gen, instead of games, I am out.
Good article Tyrus. I personally would also like to see the Kinect working better but due to its many marketing failures and poor responsiveness problems, i dont see Microsoft pumping much more money into the device. They have tried to make it work, but seeing how far they have managed to come, (fable:The Journey, Kinect Star Wars and Kinect sports) it doesnt look like we'll be seeing much better.
I use mine mainly for Dance Central or Just Dance
The only good thing to come from Kinect is all the cool hacks users have done....oh yeah and the lol worthy advertisement campaigns.

Steve920 said: Yes, Kinect is the worst thing ever to come out of Microsoft. It doesn't work. Any self-respecting consumer should have returned it to the store.


This...

Also dance central was the only good thing about it

chucky110 said: I use mine mainly for Dance Central or Just Dance



So does Usher [MOG]

Trabman said: Good article Tyrus. I personally would also like to see the Kinect working better but due to its many marketing failures and poor responsiveness problems, i dont see Microsoft pumping much more money into the device. They have tried to make it work, but seeing how far they have managed to come, (fable:The Journey, Kinect Star Wars and Kinect sports) it doesnt look like we'll be seeing much better.



Thanks mate. I saw your comment on N4G too, haha good to see you're on there as well! And yeah it's a bit saddening with what Microsoft have pumped out so far being mostly disappointing. Who knows, maybe Fable: The Journey will be of better quality, but I'm not exactly as idealistic as I was at launch.
Kinect hasn't technically "Failed" gamers. It's just that nobody has figured out how to make a game that appeals to gamers and works extremely well with the Kinect's capabilities. So, until the "Template" for good Kinect games for gamers is discovered, we'll have to stick with what we're given.
So has it perhaps "failed" developers in its capabilities?
In all honesty I use my Eyetoy more on my old PS2 than the Kinect :P
the only bad experience I've had with kincect was sonic boarders which was let down terribly by the some of the control choices.

would be great if one day we could make our own variations to the control and save it to take it to another machine though I can totally see an arm coming from no where when playing in multiplayer from stupid controls changes haha.

to the question, I don't think so but it certainly hasn't done itself any favours by getting more people on board without those gimmicky kinect features in certain traditional games.

Post a comment

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook

Recently Read

Featured Xbox 360 Content

Games of April: Your Most Anticipated?

Games of April: Your Most Anticipated?

27/03/2014 Polls 8 13
Publishers and tickets confirmed for EB Expo 2014
Gryllis 3 days News 2 7
2014 FIFA World Cup Brazil review

2014 FIFA World Cup Brazil review

Gryllis 3 days Reviews 4 8
Fox News implicates Dark Souls in murder

Fox News implicates Dark Souls in murder

Tano 3 days News 9 11
Trials Fusion review

Trials Fusion review

Tano 3 days Reviews 8 5
Destiny, Halo composer fired from Bungie ''without cause''

Destiny, Halo composer fired from Bungie ''without cause''

Gryllis 4 days News 2 9
Snoop Dogg to narrate Call of Duty: Ghosts, for realz

Snoop Dogg to narrate Call of Duty: Ghosts, for realz

Tano 4 days News 9 7
Tomb Raider 2 gameplay details surface

Tomb Raider 2 gameplay details surface

Tano 4 days News 4 6
Free-to-play is the future, says free-to-play game dev

Free-to-play is the future, says free-to-play game dev

Tano 4 days News 4 5

Community Content

A loser's review of FIFA 14
03/03/2014 Blog 12 0

MMGN Updates

Status
Updating..
Username

Kenni, soofany05, Yosho and other 2 users commented on Anime.MMGN's 2nd Anniversary

Kenni 2 hours ago
Username

Toadsili_T, zurczner, GunSlinger and other 2 users commented on Anime.MMGN's 2nd Anniversary

Toadsili_T 10 hours ago
Username

commented on 2014 FIFA World Cup Brazil review

Hugo 10 hours ago
Username

commented on Razer Blackwidow Ultimate Review

Skarteh 14 hours ago
Username

commented on 2014 FIFA World Cup Brazil review

soofany05 17 hours ago
Username

zurczner, tsubibo commented on Razer Blackwidow Ultimate Review

zurczner 1 day ago
Username

CybaCowboy posted a news - Blade Kitten 2 DLC Coming to Steam!

CybaCowboy 1 day ago
Username

CybaCowboy posted a news - Hyperdimension Neptunia: Producing Perfection Release Dates Confirmed!

CybaCowboy 1 day ago